Photo: Shades of L.A. Collection, Tessa: Digital Collections of the Los Angeles Public Library.
Photo: Shades of L.A. Collection, Tessa: Digital Collections of the Los Angeles Public Library.

‘We are here because you were there’

A defence of immigration on the grounds of history, economics and security.

Ambreen Agha is Assistant Professor at the Jindal School of International Affairs in O.P. Jindal Global University (Haryana). Her research interests include Islam, gender and conflict with emphasis on religious articulations of both violent and non-violent forms. Her writings have appeared in Outlook, Himal Southasian, Warscapes, Firstpost and other publications.

Published on

New York, 1980. An Irish American boy yells at writer Suketu Mehta and his Indian friend, "Fucking Ayatollahs!" When Mehta corrects the boy (they were Indians not Iranians), the boy retorts, "Fucking Gandhis!"

Suketu Mehta's book, This Land is Our Land: An Immigrant's Manifesto, is a political treatise on the issue of migration that makes powerful use of personal narratives. Forty years after Mehta's exchange in school, hate speech and crime still abound in the United States. By capitalising on a fear of the 'other' and appealing to majoritarian groups – leaders like Donald Trump, Viktor Orban and Narendra Modi have consolidated power. Since contemporary politics often revolves around the subject of migration, framing the immigrant 'other' as a potent threat to the country's prosperity, growth and development is a profitable electoral strategy.

Loading content, please wait...
Himal Southasian
www.himalmag.com