Join us!   We're also twittering. Come listen. |   HIMAL Special Offer   Get a 2-year subscription of Himal Southasian and receive a FREE t-shirt!!! |   NEW AT HIMAL   We Blog! |  

Rural Dalit ghetto: 'Khairlanji' by Anand Teltumbde  April 2009

By: Vijay Prashad

Khairlanji:
A strange and bitter crop

By Anand Teltumbde
Navayana, 2008
On 29 September 2006, in a modest town in eastern Maharashtra called Khairlanji, a tragedy occurred. A gang of Other Backward Castes (OBCs), led by the local Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) potentate, raided the home of a Buddhist agricultural family, the Bhotmanges. With impunity, the gang raped and killed Surekha Bhotmange and her daughter Priyanka, and killed her two sons, Sudhir and Roshan. The three children had done well in school, with Roshan on the road to becoming a computer professional and Priyanka a topper in class 10. Apart from the animosities inherent in the caste system, there was no motivation for the attack. The Bhotmanges are Dalits and their neighbours are OBCs, many of whom resented the dignified and successful lives being led by the victim family. The violence against the Bhotmanges was so extreme (the local BJP leader, Bhaskar Kadav, is accused of raping Surekha Bhotmange post-mortem) that it is impossible to discount the rage that comes from ideas of caste superiority. Those who perpetrate such atrocities visit the courthouse casually, with the full knowledge that their political friends will protect them until the case is forgotten – as so many others are.

Anand Teltumbde has now written a book that will never allow this massacre to be forgotten. Nor will it allow us to think of Khairlanji as an aberration. Since the 1970s, as Dalit communities in India organised themselves to gain political power, and since the modest benefits of affirmative action have allowed some within the community to rise in government service, attacks on Dalits have become routine. The National Crime Records Bureau shows that in 2007 alone there were more than 30,000 crimes recorded against Dalits or Scheduled Castes, of which almost 10,000 were recorded by the police under the Prevention of Atrocities Act. Human-rights groups tabulate the enormous number of rapes of Dalit women, many of whom never lodge reports due to the social sanction for such violence in general, and also because of fear of humiliation and further aggression at the police station. The violence at Khairlanji, like the violence at Melavalavu in 1999, is stunning in its detail, but also ordinary in its regularity. Such incidents have become banal – so much so, Teltumbde tells us, that the Indian media no longer pays attention. “Caste atrocities,” writes Teltumbde, “are a part of the ecology of India.” And yet, because mention of them induces guilt, the advertising-captured media ignores them.

Teltumbde may be too modest to mention that he is B R Ambedkar’s grandson, but he has the analytical acidity of his ancestor’s pen. Four years ago, he made an important intervention on the role of anti-caste struggles as part of the anti-imperialist movement. He has developed the argument that, in the postcolonial era, Brahmins and other ‘elevated’ castes moved from the rural areas to the cities, where they benefited from the openings afforded them by the new state. In the rural areas, it was the intermediate castes and OBCs, the Shudras, who benefited from the modest land reforms, and it was they who became the immediate oppressor of the Dalits (bear in mind that 70 percent of Dalits in India are landless cultivators). In this way, Teltumbde writes, the Shudras became the “virtual baton holders for Brahmanism”. The Shudra-dominant castes have also become the “main prop of the Hindutva movement”, as was documented in detail in Teltumbde’s edited collection Hindutva and Dalits (Samya, 2005). These analytical moves allow Teltumbde to identify the problem at hand in Khairlanji, one of India’s many rural ghettos. The contradiction between the Shudra landholders (who are aligned with the BJP and Shiv Sena) and this Dalit Buddhist family is writ large in the tragedy that visited the Bhotmange family.

Strengthening caste
Between the 1970s and the 1990s, certain region-specific Shudra castes took advantage of agricultural inputs from the government and land reforms to consolidate their economic position in the countryside. Money and land in hand, they turned to the political domain, and became the backbone of many of the regional parties – including the Telugu Desam, Shiv Sena and Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam – that were able to exert themselves after the Congress lost its hegemony in Maharashtra and in South India by the 1980s. Dalits, meanwhile, did not have access to land, and they therefore could not position themselves to claim political power. To complicate matters further, in Maharashtra the Dalit vote was split after 1958 into a series of discordant parties, all of which claim Ambedkar as their own. When liberalisation soured the rural economy from 1991 onward, the Shudras turned on the Dalits, who had no effective political shield to protect them.

After the Khairlanji massacre, a local women’s organisation in the neighbouring town of Bhandara, the Rashtriya Sambuddha Mahila Sanghatana, conducted the first protest. This was followed by the formation of the Khairlanji Dalit Hatyakhand Kruti Samiti, through the initiative of the Mahila Jan Andolan Samiti – whose leader, the Communist Party of India (Marxist)-aligned Ashu Saxena, was unduly harassed by the government, which spent far more energy moving against the activists than against the perpetrators. Dalit political parties were wary of taking the lead, with R S Gawai of the Republican Party of India (RPI) allegedly telling the local government to suppress the news of the massacre. (Teltumbde believes that this was for lack of commitment, although it might also have been for lack of nerve – many leaders, such as Gawai, feared that the huge numbers of Dalits present at the Diksha Divas celebrations might have run riot from Nagpur to Khairlanji.) In November, 25,000 people flocked to the Amravati rally organised by the Khairlanji Nished Kruti Samiti, and many more followed. The national media picked up the story grudgingly, and even then only when pushed by the fact-finding visits of various human-rights groups, and the visits of the CPI (M)’s Brinda Karat and the RPI’s Prakash Ambedkar.

In the end, it is the lack of political representation that rightly irks Teltumbde. He does not pay much heed to the bahujan portmanteau (referring to OBCs, Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and other minorities). He even worries that such parties are keener to strengthen caste than to annihilate it – as he wrote in his 2004 book, “Caste is intrinsically divisive.” Against caste, for its annihilation, Teltumbde has created a solid corpus of work that bears witness to the degradation of Indian democracy, and to the capacity of Indian socialism. India’s revolution, to paraphrase Bhagat Singh, is sharpened on the anvil of Teltumbde’s thoughts.


Comments

Please note that offensive posts will be removed.

If I speak in the Cheap Authentic NFL Jerseys tongues of men and of angels, but have not love, I am only a resounding gong or a clanging cymbal. If I have the gift of prophecy and can fathom all mysteries and all Official NFL Jerseys knowledge, and if I have a faith that can move mountains, but have not love, I am nothing. If I give all I possess to the poor and surrender my USA Jerseys Shop body to the flames,but have not love, I gain nothing.Love is patient, NFL Jerseys love is kind. It does not envy, it does not boast, it is not proud. It is not rude, it is not self-seeking, it is not easily angered, it NHL Jerseys keeps no record of wrongs. Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth. It always protects, always trusts, always MLB Jerseys hopes, always perseveres.Love never NHL Hockey Jerseys fails. But where there are prophecies, they will cease; where there are tongues, they will be stilled; where there is knowledge, it will pass away. For we know in part and we prophesy in MLB Baseball Jerseys part, but when perfection comes, the imperfect disappea. When I was a child, I talked like a child, I thought like a child, I reasoned like a child. When I became a NBA Basketball Jerseys man, I put childish ways behind me. Now we see but a poor reflection as in a mirror; then we shall see face to face. Now I know in part; then I shall know fully, even as I am fully known.And now these three remain: faith, hope and NFL Football Jerseys love. But the greatest of these is love.

LIJ
NFL Football Jerseys
shanghai
2010-09-09 07:09:09
zhouyun Here I would like to introduce you to the louis vuitton outlet. The wild leather discreetly embossed with the signature louis vuitton and overlapping investment in cotton canvas, which belongs to the louis vuitton handbags, And Mohave weekend louis vuitton bags is actually a functional bag. With 19.3 cm x 13.4 cm x 11.4 measured there is ample space for everyday use, holiday travel for business or family. Open the zipper, two pockets. It can be done by hand on the shoulder or Louis Vuitton Wallets across the body with a comfortable handle and a removable, From louis vuitton Online Shop. zhouyun Gucci Bags has gained and maintained its leading edge over the past decades as a luxury goods in the world of fashion industry. When it refers to the Gucci Handbags design and elegance, no other brands can compete with Gucci Outlet for its graceful appearance and noble quality. You can't find any bags best than Gucci handbags. Discount Gucci handbags have different colors and styles, there will be one to meet your needs.Many times certain colors or styles will go on sale after the season has ended. You’ll get your hands on an authentic Gucci soon enough. Gucci men wallets are also very fashion. No matter Gucci Hobo Handbags or Gucci women wallets are loved by men and women. The chatacters of Gucci wallets are bright color but with the characters of mature and steady. How about buying Gucci bags or Gucci Walltes now? zhouyun

Coach Outlet have rarely been ultra trendy. It's a brand that always had a more understated, even sturdy design sense. If you know something about Coach Bags, you know it follows suit. That's why it's got me so annoyed Coach Handags lately to keep hearing how the Coach Outlet Store Online, and most specifically the patchwork bags that were such a hit last year were just a passing trend, and not worth buying anymore, now that the buzz is over. Buzz? Coach Wallets is timeless baby! I hope this will help to put an end to all this silly gossip that Coach handbags were a last-year thing. It's really ridiculous. Coach Jewelry just the kind of people who don't know much about Coach would say such things. Or, I don't know, am I the one who's been deceived? Am I the only person who thinks Coach is the farthest thing from a trend-only kind of designer? Buy Discount Coach Handbags.

zhouyun When asked about the reasons for luxury goods price adjustment, gina that, chanel bags periodic price hikes are inevitable every year, prices of luxury goods every year to raise the threshold through the chanel online. Last month, however, is a relatively large price adjustments in the industry believe that the main reason for chanel handbags is the larger euro.December 31, 2009, 1 euro was 9.7971 yuan, and by July 29, 2010, 1 euro 8.8532 yuan. Domestic terms Chanel Handbags 2010, the euro, and renminbi to buy European luxury goods cheaper prices. On the purchase of parts and raw materials from global luxury brand in Europe, the chanel jewelry also means shrinking profits and costs. Therefore, chanel purses though the world price adjustment across the board, but throughout the range of price adjustment is not the same as the rate of Asia to counter rising far as Europe, thus narrowing the difference brought about by chanel 2.55 bags rate. zhouyun These are the pair of shoes, and feel MBT Shoes better than the base. Uniquely designed for a wide range of internal or permanent muscle. The result is promoting metabolism, burn calories,salama mbt, strengthening and belly,panda mbt, legs MBT Tembea Mink and Cheap Anti Shoes back. Negative heel helps you align the spine of the first project zhuzhu MBT Shoes Sale On MBT Chili Sale manner, while MBT Shoes Reviews maintaining the second rock Womens MBT Shoes strength minimum weight on the pressure under the Arch of the foot. This shared on heel and forefoot, and through the arches less pressure results. Make sure that you adjust the MBT Sport Sneakers mens MBT Shoes size is correct and you want to go to a local authorized dealer, is installed correctly. zhouyun Now we present you a few shots of what supra shoes has set to release as part of their Holiday 2010 collection. Pictures are two new colorways of the supra skytop one in black/white and the other in red/black.There is also a supras in purple, a Supra Society Shoes in maroon, a Supra Vaider in black/red and another in black/blue. Follow the jump to have a closer look at all the Supra skytop high and stay tuned to kissbrand.com, we will keep you posted about these supra skytop 2.Supra shoes Sale gives us a first look at their TUF Black Tape Pack. The pack will consist of three sneaker, all in which is introduced in a red and black colorway. The shoe’s that are
wedding
tyh64uhy
2010-09-08 02:09:11
Cutting costs with your junior bridesmaid dresses may help towards a sculptured ice figurine of (Brad Pitt) a guarantee to make most women happy.A fabulous way forward in saving the pennies is to design your wedding invitation wording and prom dresses ; a good printing kit will give a professional look to your finished work. Check with hairstyles and wedding hairstyles service providers for advice on how to do this, you will find that some are very willing and obliging.What kind of cheap wedding dresses you have planned is best set in your mind before deciding what wedding invitations to send. Is this wedding going to be grand or simple. Depending on your budget you can have a bit of both?
wedding
tyh64uhy
2010-09-07 12:09:26

Share it »                                                                                                  

Send your comment

Fields with * are required fields.









 

Web Exclusive

 
 

New riverbed carved through Choglamsar

Where once stood houses by Dilip D’Souza

Ladakh after the flood.
More
The Kashmiri and the Indian Shivam Vij writes about how (and why) people-to-people dialogue is the best way out of the Kashmir logjam.
.The battle for bauxite Sudha Ramachandran writes about the Dongria Kondhs of southern Orissa who are up in arms on the grounds that their land, culture and way of life, their very survival as a distinct tribe, is under serious threat from UK mining giant Vedanta Resources.
More

Online Poll

Bandhs: 'Coercion' or 'Democratic protest'?
Coercion & blackmail
My democratic right.
I sit on the fence.
Holiday! :-)
 
GET OUR FREE NEWSLETTER Register to receive news and alerts every month.